Justia Contracts Opinion Summaries

After meeting with Robert Swendra, an insurance agent selling American Family Insurance products, Curtis Graff purchased an automobile policy and an umbrella policy. Based on Swendra's representations, Graff wrongfully believed the umbrella policy contained $1 million in underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage. Later, Graff injured his back in a car accident with an underinsured motorist. Graff filed a complaint alleging breach of contract against American Family and negligent procurement of insurance coverage against the Swendra Agency. After Graff entered into a settlement agreement with American Family Graff's contract claim against American Family was dismissed, and the negligence claim against the Swendra Agency proceeded to trial. The jury found Swendra Agency liable and awarded damages. Pursuant to the collateral source statute, the district court reduced the damages award by $200,260. The court of appeals affirmed. The Supreme Court affirmed, holding (1) the court of appeals did not err in finding that Graff's release of American Family did not extinguish Graff's claim against the Swendra Agency, and (2) the district court properly excluded the attorney fees paid to Graff's counsel from the collateral source calculation.